Post by secane on Apr 17, 2013 12:36:39 GMT 8
Sent 57 minutes ago
From Secane
To Michael Brock
Subject Please help. Seeking Clarification on Animal-Companion-type Mounts for PFS. Disagreeing with VC
To Michael Brock,
Hi, my name is Sean Shia and I'm a player/gm from Singapore's PFS group.
Sorry for troubling you, but there is a current disagreement with my VC on what list of mounts are available for the Bonded Mount, Divine Bond and Mount class abilities of the Nature Oracle, Paladin and Cavalier, respectively.
My VC, Richard, states that as the FAQ writes "another source grants access to additional creature choices.". The above classes can now select creatures like Axebeaks, Giant Chameleon and other more exotic mount choices, as Ultimate Equipment, Animal Archive, and the Bestiaries are sources that have opened up "access" for the above classes.
I maintain that my interpretation of "another source grants access", means a boon or an archetype that opens up "access" to more mount options for these classes.
Does the fact that the books above now have more mounts available for PFS, means that the above 3 classes can select from a wider range of mounts? Or is the list of mounts they have access to still limited to their respective class abilities? (meaning only horses, camels, pony, wolf, boar and dog mounts.)
Another equally important question is, what is defined as a source? Are Books sources? Or individual feats/classes/boons?
I would really appreciate clarification on this matter.
Richard is a great VC, and has gone out of his way to clarify rules and helping new GMs. This matter is simply one that has reach the end of any further discussion and now requires intervention from a higher authority.
Thank you.
Best Regards,
Sean Shia
From Secane
To Michael Brock
Subject Please help. Seeking Clarification on Animal-Companion-type Mounts for PFS. Disagreeing with VC
To Michael Brock,
Hi, my name is Sean Shia and I'm a player/gm from Singapore's PFS group.
Sorry for troubling you, but there is a current disagreement with my VC on what list of mounts are available for the Bonded Mount, Divine Bond and Mount class abilities of the Nature Oracle, Paladin and Cavalier, respectively.
My VC, Richard, states that as the FAQ writes "another source grants access to additional creature choices.". The above classes can now select creatures like Axebeaks, Giant Chameleon and other more exotic mount choices, as Ultimate Equipment, Animal Archive, and the Bestiaries are sources that have opened up "access" for the above classes.
I maintain that my interpretation of "another source grants access", means a boon or an archetype that opens up "access" to more mount options for these classes.
Does the fact that the books above now have more mounts available for PFS, means that the above 3 classes can select from a wider range of mounts? Or is the list of mounts they have access to still limited to their respective class abilities? (meaning only horses, camels, pony, wolf, boar and dog mounts.)
Another equally important question is, what is defined as a source? Are Books sources? Or individual feats/classes/boons?
I would really appreciate clarification on this matter.
Richard is a great VC, and has gone out of his way to clarify rules and helping new GMs. This matter is simply one that has reach the end of any further discussion and now requires intervention from a higher authority.
Thank you.
Best Regards,
Sean Shia
Sent 47 minutes ago
From Michael Brock
To Secane
Subject Re: Please help. Seeking Clarification on Animal-Companion-type Mounts for PFS. Disagreeing with VC Reply
The three classes are still limited to their respective class abilities.